?

Log in

No account? Create an account

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Harry Potter 7

Okay, I've read through Book 7. Another weekend I'll never get back.

You can all post spoilers now.

Why on Earth do people pre-order a book, and then stand in line for it?

Tags:

Comments

( 10 comments — Leave a comment )
partly_bouncy
22nd Jul, 2007 13:54 (UTC)
The book: It was disappointing. It needed a good editor. JKR did too much telling, not enough showing. It could have done with 100 less pages. Parts of it were really confusing because of the amount of back story and explanation she tried to input in it.

And the epilogue just was rather disappointing from a feminist viewpoint, hoping for some redemption for the kind of poor treatment of female characters who played second fiddle to male characters or who were otherwise attracted to male characters who were written as inferior to them. :/

I wasn't a huge fan coming in. I am certainly not a huge fan now. If I spend too much time thinking about it, I will hate it.
hawkeye7
22nd Jul, 2007 23:02 (UTC)
However the female characters do marry male characters who are socially superior to them; the mudblood Hermione marries the pureblood Ron; Ginny, from a poor but pure family, marries the wealthy and famous Harry Potter.
partly_bouncy
23rd Jul, 2007 01:36 (UTC)
In the case of Hermione, she marries a male who is frequently depicted as intellectually inferior, kind of unattractive and more socially inept than she was. That's still a step down to a certain degree for her. If she had say married Krum, it would have been much more a step up.

And we don't know what Hermione and Ginny did. No one seemed to recognize them 19 years later. That seems to imply they hold no current status of importance, no power position where parents would talk about them. Ron and Harry, yeah, they get talked about. Not the women.

This whole thing kind of just annoys me and I don't know how to express my feelings in a way that isn't wanky. I really loathe that in the end, all that discussion about what they would do after Hogwarts was for nothing. Harry, Ginny, Ron, Hermione raise beautiful babies who fall into the same stereotypes as their parents and persist in the same patterns which had already been shown as not necessarily healthy. And just GAH!
hawkeye7
23rd Jul, 2007 13:06 (UTC)
Ron's comment that he is famous is intentionally ironic - everybody is actually gawking at old scarface.

It reminded me of "The Breakfast Club" where they wonder if they are destined to become like their parents and realise that they already are.
jthijsen
22nd Jul, 2007 19:14 (UTC)
I liked it mostly, except for one huge fault: why didn't they call for Kreacher when they inadvertently led the death eaters to Harry's house? I mean, he could have gotten them food while they were camping out, cooked it a lot better than Harry or Hermione and done some major scouting. Not to mention keeping them in touch with the order of the phoenix.

But even smart Hermione never even thought about it. And this really, really bugged me enough to distract me for several pages.
mistraltoes
23rd Jul, 2007 01:01 (UTC)
Either you missed that bit or I imagined it, but I don't think I imagined it: they decided not to summon Kreacher because they didn't know whether the Ministry could track house-elf powers and follow Kreacher to their hiding place. The mention was very brief, blink-and-you-miss it, though.
jthijsen
23rd Jul, 2007 18:58 (UTC)
I must've blinked again, then. I reread that part this evening and other than the gang missing Kreacher's cooking, I could find no mention of him.
mistraltoes
24th Jul, 2007 06:58 (UTC)
I had another look, and it's not precisely where I expected it to be. In my edition, it's Chapter 14, bottom of the eleventh page:

He and Hermione had already decided against trying to summon him; what if someone from the Ministry came too? They could not count on elfish Apparition being free from the same flaw that had taken Yaxley to Grimmauld Place on the hem of Hermione's sleeve.

So I wasn't entirely correct; the concern was about someone coming with Kreacher rather than someone tracking him, but at least they thought about it.
hawkeye7
24th Jul, 2007 09:39 (UTC)
On page 229 in my copy.
jthijsen
24th Jul, 2007 19:07 (UTC)
You're absolutely right, found it right there.

I think my main reason for being ticked off was that I was worried about Kreacher, too, and because I missed this, I thought Harry hadn't given it a second thought. Glad to know I was wrong. And they were wrong, too, Kreacher apparently left the house safely, or he wouldn't have been able to lead the Hogwarts' house-elves charge at the end.
( 10 comments — Leave a comment )